I never imagined that customs for Islamic women to wear facecloth can cause misunderstandings. Because most times I saw them were on the TV, and they all walking or sitting in a dessert where there were few people. After I learned this problem, I surfed on the Internet to know more and now I want to share some information.
France, a nation which contains the most Islamic people in European, forced all the Islamic women in France should not wear niqub or burqa in public. What’s worse, people who use religious reasons to force Islamic women to dress like that will also be charged and punished. President Nicolas Sarkozy claimed that such dressing shows disrespect to those women, and it should not be welcomed. Of course, those words just indicate where the president was standing and may not be very objective. Nevertheless, Holland is totally support this statute and plans to follow it.
On the other side, Britain government states clearly that Britain will not take actions like France on account of its principle of respecting each religion’s culture and customs.
The above is what different countries have done to cope with this troublesome religious problem, and now we need an objective angle to discuss it and try to find a solution.
First reason for France is obviously the security. I believe some serious incidents must have occurred in France which push it to lay down the controversial law. It is common sense that people who can’t be distinguished from faces are truly dangerous. Additionally, terrorists may exploit this to disguise themselves as Islamic women to do something horrible but be able to escape arrest.
Secondly, amounts of citizens will feel a little panic when they meet someone wearing veil. In that situation, it may cause inconvenience in public service industry.
The third reason is just like what the president has claimed. Some French officers hold the view that women dressing like that mean discriminating against them, because only some low-status women need to wear something to cover their faces in Islam. And facecloth is the symbol of religious persecution which is not supposed to take place in a civilization society.
However, there are also many reasonable points against the decree.
The strongest point is that every religion has its own and unique customs, a great nation is supposed to be able to contain them instead of forcing them to assimilate in specific cultures. Only when a country could achieve this, it can be called civilization society.
As is shown on the internet, after a Re-veiling event in the 1970s, women changed their original ideas on the veils and added religious faith in wearing veils. And they even consider it as national consciousness and a holy symbol.
As is mentioned above, it’s truly hard to judge the right and the wrong. Every side has their justifications to defend their benefits among cultural conflicts. When it comes to me, I tend to support a neutral solution. Just as the Islamic women don’t cover their faces but only their heads in Singapore, I think this custom should be spread to France. In that case, the Islam can reserve their own customs and offer convenience to French government at the same time.
References to the article
